Prioritizing “No Significant Harm” over “Reasonable and Equitable” in Governance of Aquifers
This commentary reflects on the governance of transboundary aquifers and suggests that the principle of “no significant harm” should ultimately be prioritized over that of “reasonable and equitable use.”
Two principles of both transboundary aquifer management and governance have come to hold pre-eminent positions in negotiations:
-
In all operations to reduce as far as possible any significant harm to other portions of the aquifer and to other natural resources with which it is related.
-
Ensure that use of the aquifer water is reasonable and equitable by comparison with other possible uses and other possible users.
The author remarks that, while the development of these principles is an achievement, balance between the two can be difficult to achieve. It is often not clear which principle should get priority, when and with what constraints. Brooks discusses various perspectives in the literature, and provides case studies of the al-Disi Aquifer under Saudi Arabia and Jordan, and the Ogallala Aquifer, which lies under several states in the United States, to examine key questions and issues when considering these principles.
You might also be interested in
The Chemical Analysis of Fresh Water (Third Edition)
This publication describes the protocols used in the IISD Experimental Lakes Area Analytical Service Laboratory for the measurement of chemical constituents in freshwater samples.
IISD Annual Report 2023–2024
While IISD's reputation as a convenor, a trusted thought leader, and a go-to source on key issues within the sustainable development field is stronger than ever, the work happening outside the spotlight is just as valuable.
We all have to keep plastics out of our lakes and rivers
In an opinion piece, IISD-ELA's Pauline Gerrard writes that researchers in Toronto found an average of 123 microplastics in one serving of freshwater fish, vastly more than the nine microplastics ingested in a serving of grocery store Alaska pollock found in a study by the same authors published earlier this year.
Cottagers fear time running out for containing zebra mussels in Clear Lake
Clear Lake cottage owners fear crucial time is being lost in efforts to contain invasive zebra mussels, after an underwater curtain was dislodged by the wind and waves two days after being installed. For Scott Higgins, a senior research scientist with IISD-ELA, the fact Parks Canada has not reported new discoveries of live adults or "veligers," free-floating microscopic young mussels, is good news. The bad news is that water samples contained environmental DNA, which suggests there could be some living mussels, although likely in small numbers.